Thursday, March 27, 2008

19th day, friday: aftermath and presentation

080321_13th compound_friday

Aftermath: it was gone. A group defended it from people taking it to sell the bottles. That group brought it into their factory, and later dismantled it and sold the plastic bottles for 140 R. They said if we gave them a real couch, they would have kept it, as they cant make money out of it. They liked the intervention and wished for more things like that…


18th day, thursday: 13th Compound; intervention

080320_13th compound_thursday

Intervention: we made a couch from plastic bottles, string and tape (we sold the surplus bottles for 30R). At lunchtime, we placed it under a canopy in one of the compound streets, at a T-junction with a small lane, and recorded how people reacted. People were timid at first, then tested its durability, sat down and socialized with eachother.

17th day, wednesday: 13th Compound; answers

080319_13th compound_wednesday

13th Compound: another contact:

Met with a 100+ yr old woman who was the first one to arrive to the 13th Compound. She constructed her house after filling the marsh with sand and mud. She lives in the residential Kabba Walla Compound on the other side of the 60ft rd. Most of the people here collect waste from Mumbai, and store in the upstairs of their house.

16th day, tuesday: 13th Compound; interviews

13th Compound: more contacts:

Met with an owner of a plastic recycling factory, a doctor, and a former political leader today. All of these men have experienced decline in business in the wake of future development, and high electricity prices.

3RD WEEK: 15th day, monday: 13th Compound; industries

080317_13th compound_monday

13th Compound:

We have noticed that EVERYTHING HAPPENS ON THE STREET: sorting, storing, hammering, assembling, washing, thoroughfare, trucks, carts, bags on head, gutters;

self-washing, clothes-washing, cooking, eating, buying, selling; socializing at corners, under a canopy, at unused space.

14th day, sunday: kashid beach

080316_kashid beach_sunday

Kashid Beach: decided to stay the night…

We had so many conversations with children, families, locals, drunk men on annual day out from Mumbai. They liked taking pictures of us…

13th day, saturday: kashid beach

080315_kashid beach_saturday

Aaaaaaaaaaah… Kashid Beach

Train taxi ferry bus rickshaw: 6 hrs – worth it. Sun, fresh air, cool breeze, T-shirts, coconuts, goan curry.

11th, thursday: 13th Compound; introduction

080320_13th compound_thursday

13th Compound: Introduction; periphery walk

The largest recycling centre in the world, and the biggest money-maker in Dharavi. Pressure and prime development zone: near to Bandra Kurla Complex and Mahim Railway Station. Pollution and space: won’t adjust to future development.

12th day, friday: 13th Compound; contacts

080314_13th compound_friday

13th Compound:

Today we met with the leader of the 13th Compound, who was just elected president of ‘Dharavi Businessmen’s Welfare Association.’ Then we got a tour of the area and got to see all sorts of industries: plastic sorting; plastic, tin can recycling; soap production. These raw materials are sold to companies from the outside.

10th day, wednesday: Mumbai Tour

080312_Mumbai_tour_wednesday

Tour of Mumbai: fishing village, Navi Mumbai, artist’s village & Chowpatty Beach.

Fishing village provided insight into what Dharavi might have been like 100 years ago.

Navi Mumbai suggested what future Dharavi might look like, with its corporate ‘Las Vegas’- like buildings.

Rediscovering Dharavi with author, in Shivar Guesthouse

9th day, tuesday: map 90 ft road morning

080311_Dharavi_90ft rd_tuesday

at all times, the junction condition with 60 ft rd separate 90 ft rd into 2 parts.
temporary / fixed...

activities: quanititavely recorded; lots of activity at night
movement: peak @ junctions esp. at night; dramatic change after crossing the 60 ft rd to the south (near the power station)
space: counted steps; felt big/small/open/straight; repetitive; corner of buildings follow curve of road - material, green, garbage, making; wider @ end; different after junction w/ 60 ft rd - wider, vegetation, footpath; municipal buildings - different treatment of space - parking/trees; range between quality of shops - advertisement is key; skyline different @ junction; night - feel presence of cars, new road of commerce

WEEK 2: 8th day, monday: map 90 ft rd: night

080310_90ft rd_night_monday

the task this week was to document key roads in Dharavi. 90 ft rd was our assignment. morning, day, and night. the night proved to be intimidating at one point...

90 ft rd is a very pedestrian, always energetic, retail orientated (90%) formal road that provides a vehicular link from the sion-mahim rd to the 60 ft road and beyond. very few residential elements can be seen (like tenement block gated entrances, or dark alleys/side-streets), until you cross the 60 ft road. business. delivery. thoroughfare. access.

7th day, sunday: elephant island

080309_elephant island_sunday

FRESH AIR!!! SEA BREEZE!!!
lovely day...

click above to see the carved temples of elephant island

6th day, saturday: ghandi, temples, bandra

080308_Mumbai_temples_saturday

click above to see today's tour of Ghandi's house, muslim mosque in the ocean, and hindu temple on the waterfront.

Dharavi Development Project: Mukesh Mehta

bandra to north. dharavi slum to south. mangroves and river in between.

1950-2000: major pop. increase. 1996: govt: develop Dharavi as financial centre.

Mukesh Mehta scheduled to make $600m...

Spatial restructuring: relax zoning; transport and infrastructure; business; housing; amenities (malls, museums)

Tenant

Prove tenancy in Mumbai pre 1995

225 sq ft / family in tower slum

schools, museums, clinics; infrastructure, services, higher quality housing

(currently 1 toilet / 700ppl: use toilet at work / railway)

Developer:

$3bn = Dharavi Redevelopment

INCENTIVES: 10% Dharavi land for sale; subsidised accom. for squatters; 1.333 FSI

1 school, welfare office, society office / 100 huts (currently 625 huts / ha)

Must house existing mosque/temple/school in new development (ie, in 5-star hotel)

If works w/ NGO: concessions

must know exactly how many families to rehouse (ID cards)

produce exported to rich areas; wants to cut out middle man and bring rich area to Dharavi...

internationally acclaimed buildings and architects

Mumbai and Metropolitan Lecture: JJ school of architecture

david harvey - capitolism and urbanisation

mumbai history:

sultanates before british and portuguese
1600s: East India Trading Company; Bombay natural harbour - collection of islands - fishing villages.
1800s: land reclaimed; ppl shifted around;
Bombay = several layers (no chronology) integrated into eachother
Bombay = new developments imposed on older developments
hard to tell new from old...
organic form vs. grid city


India trying to compete with Shanghai, Hong Kong and Singapore
building boom: 500 euro / sq. m

Dharavi: near airport and Bandra Kurla business complex; at centre of Mumbai bounded by east and west railways; beside rich jaya neighbourhood
Dharavi will be 'South Bandra Business Complex'

Dharavi = economic power - doesn't compare with land prices
v. important to working of city- integral part of Mumbai

urban sprawl: 1000ppl / 0.03 acre no open space…

densest on east and western railway to colaba
earthquake zone: max 70m tall building

informal sector = 68% employment of city (no tax)

globalization + urbanization = urban poverty

Mumbai = 15m ppl (60% in squatter settlements)


Dharavi = 6m ppl

no town planner in local government

slum growth rate = 8% (2% = other growth)


slum dweller wants:

1. job & skills

2. $

3. health

4. house


6 ppl / hut = 10 sq m (2ppl earn $)

80% living in Dharavi, work in Dharavi


noone dealing with urban migration



Day 3, tuesday: sensual walk through Dharavi

080304_Dharavi_walk through_tuesday

our group walked east to west from sion station to mahim station, getting very lost along the way. this map is hopeless...

click above to see the visual documentation.

what struck me today was the calmer sense of the nagars with respect to the busy, noisy roads around the perimeter in yesterdays experience.
the density of the blocks of ppl living squashed together. the darkness and narrowness of tiny alleys with gutters and pipes on the ground, and electrical conduits at my head height. there is only enough space for 1 person to walk, but you manage 2 depending on how you can step over gutters...
the darkness of these alleys makes you appreciate the 'light at the end of the tunnel' and small spaces deep inside the community providing respite.
women seem to be in these small alleys, monitoring their nagar and socialising with eachother.
we came across 1 large public space (cricket and parking) and some small public niches today (water well, toilet, washing).
main streets are busy, ppl selling everything, ppl going through rubbish, children following us everywhere. it feels very safe.
strong contrast between the established, clean, legal community of the Koli Wada and its dirty, industrial surroundings. women making poppadoms in communal space, kids playing.

ppl asking us why we're here. now we have some contacts. political figures in areas. large vast areas of filth. ppl all doing something. kids everywhere, no supervision, follow us for ages. some important looking elderly men sit in shade at street corner. this is their turf. but we're welcome...

cross the bridge over the railway, out of dharavi now. this is much nicer. trees. hospital. nice residences.

Dharavi history: lecture in Shivar Guesthouse by Bhau Korde

bandra to north. dharavi slum to south. mangroves and river in between.

1600s: Koli Wada

1880s: Leather tanning; muslims from south; entrepreneurs bring village

1950s: Land Reclamation

1970s: Garment business; muslims from north; export to Italian industries

Dharavi = place where any poor man can live and make a living. struggle. generations. growth.

diversity. density. harmony.

Christmas and New Year: all religions celebrate together

politicians: what i think...

1970: offer housing; 60-70 sq. m; politicians control area

internal community justice: come together to sort problems. dialogue. no police.

80% ppl already sold house. what do ppl need?

leave them be - no govt. help

just infrastructure - maybe rent spaces for small businesses (they will pay)

- not public space (they use prayer rooms, outdoor sq. etc)


if ppl sell for short term money and move out, travel 60km to work, no life. cycle restarts.

must let communities live together.

everyone earns in Dharavi. all working.

Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Day 2, monday: sensual walk around dharavi

080303_Dharavi_walk around_monday

kevin, dayo, stephan meet sonam and daksha from the JJ.
task to walk the whole periphery of dharavi with our gps, recording the 5 senses. see. touch/feel. hear. smell. collective experience.
we decided to record from -5 to +5 how intense your specific sense is at various moments. how will they relate to eachother?

click above to see the sight documented from medium range and some close-ups, and also our collective experiences.